GoHotelly
2-star hotel Check-in 15:00 ·

Mystic Moose Resort

Experience Mystic Moose Resort in Hayward, WI with a 4.7 rating, boat rentals, and nearby attractions like Lake Chippewa and Moose Lake. Book now!

7611 W Pine Point Rd, Hayward, WI 54843, United States View on map
9.4/10
Exceptional Based on 51 recent guest reviews
What recent guests emphasize

Mystic Moose Resort Stands Out for Personalized Hospitality and Scenic Outdoor Experiences

Recent visitors frequently highlight the attentive and friendly owners, clean and well-equipped cabins, and plentiful recreational options centered around fishing and lakeside activities. The resort offers a peaceful, family-friendly environment well-suited for relaxation and exploration.

Guests often praise

  • Warm, welcoming hosts who go above and beyond to assist and engage with guests, including providing personalized fishing tips and errands support.
  • Immaculately clean and comfortable cabins with functional kitchens and cozy atmospheres.
  • Abundant on-site activities such as fishing, boat rentals (pontoon, fishing boats, paddle boats), kayaking, and a playground for children.
  • Scenic lakefront location with private access to piers, fishing spots, and peaceful natural surroundings.
  • Well-stocked bait shop and small convenience store on the property, making supplies easily accessible without needing to travel into town.

Worth knowing

  • The resort emphasizes tranquility and seclusion, making it less suitable for guests seeking busy, nightlife-oriented vacations.
  • Internet access is available but may be limited to common areas rather than full cabin coverage.
  • The overall experience is centered on outdoor recreation and relaxation rather than luxury resort amenities.
  • While praised for cleanliness and maintenance, some guests note the rustic nature of cabins and facilities suitable for a lakeside retreat rather than a high-end resort.
  • Reservations and communication with the owners before arrival are encouraged to ensure personalized service and activity planning.

Best for

  • Families and multi-generational groups looking for a quiet, nature-focused getaway with activities for all ages.
  • Fishing enthusiasts seeking expert local advice, easy lake access, and well-maintained boats.
  • Visitors who value personalized hospitality and a homey, welcoming atmosphere.
  • Those wanting a clean, comfortable lakeside cabin experience in a peaceful and scenic environment.
  • Guests looking to explore local lakes and enjoy outdoor recreation such as kayaking, paddle boating, and campfires.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Mystic Moose Resort

Located on W Pine Point Road in Hayward, Wisconsin, Mystic Moose Resort offers a tranquil lakeside setting ideal for visitors looking to enjoy outdoor recreation and relaxation. This resort hotel features clean, cozy cabins managed by attentive hosts who provide a welcoming and family-friendly atmosphere. The property includes amenities such as boat rentals, including canoes, kayaks, paddle boats, and fishing boats, with on-site bait and ice available to support guests’ fishing excursions.

The resort is well-suited for families and groups of all ages, as reflected in guest reviews praising the variety of activities and the hosts’ personal touches, such as fishing guidance and thoughtful extras for children. Recreational options extend to a playground, bonfire area, and direct access to a pier for fishing, contributing to a peaceful and engaging stay. The surrounding area offers opportunities to explore nearby lakes including Lake Chippewa, Lost Land Lake, and Moose Lake, all popular with visitors interested in water-based leisure.

Guest feedback highlights the cleanliness of the cabins and boats, the helpfulness of the owners, and the quiet, secluded nature of the location. The accommodation is especially appealing for those who prefer a calm environment for fishing and nature appreciation, away from crowded or busy resorts. While the property scores well overall with a 4.7 rating, its suitability is particularly noted for travelers focused on sightseeing, recreation, and easy access to local attractions.

Conveniently reachable by car within about 1.5 hours from Gogebic - Iron County Airport, Mystic Moose Resort combines a rustic retreat experience with practical facilities, making it a solid choice for visitors seeking a peaceful getaway in the northern Wisconsin lake region.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

AD
Angela Damask Apr 19, 2026
10

This place is absolutely breathtaking. Joel and Sara take care of everything there. The nicest people. The cabins were very clean. The views were spectacular. They had canoes and kayaks and games to play and a paddle boat for free to use. Plus tons more things to do. It was so amazing to walk out the front door to the pier to fish. I’m already looking forward to next year. Thank you Joel and Sara!!

TM
Tanya Mat Apr 06, 2026
10

Perfect family resort for ALL ages! Our group of 14 had the most wonderful time staying here last week! This was our second time staying at the resort and we will definitely be back year after year. Joel and Sara ALWAYS go above and beyond...even gave the kids some yummy popsicles. Our 9 year old is still talking about all the fishing tips, tricks, and "secret spots" that Joel told him...and loved the late night crawfish fishing. We rented a pontoon boat for the week and had a blast fishing and exploring the lake. The cabins and boats are very clean and well maintained. They had bait and ice right on the property so you didnt need to travel into town. Kids had a blast making smores around the fireplace and playing on the playground. I can go on and on about how wonderful this place is....great memories made!

MS
Mary Sinkenberg Mar 02, 2026
10

We had a wonderful time here. The owners are very accommodating. Sarah was going into town and asked if we needed any supplies. Very clean cabins and grounds. Our small dog was welcomed by the Musket who was very friendly. Cant wait til next year!

LG
Lacee Gassman Feb 02, 2026
10

We have stayed at this resort for two years in a row, and it is every bit a five-star resort. Joel and Sarah are fantastic hosts and always make sure that our needs as guests are met. They are more than happy to answer calls prior to our arrival and offer advice on what we'll need for our stay. For each of our stays, Joel has taken the time to take us out on his boat to show us potential fishing spots. Throughout our visits, he has always checked in to see if we were successful fishing and offered advice on other spots on the lake to try. We always look forward to our stays and are excited about spending another week here next year!

CH
Cameron Hybels Jan 31, 2026
10

Our four families had the pleasure of staying at the Mystic Moose for a week in July. We rented 3 of the 4 cabins. The cabins were very clean and the kitchens were equipped with everything we needed. We rented a pontoon boat and Lund fishing boat for the week. The boats were in great condition and allowed us to explore the beautiful lake. Upon arrival, Joel took us on a boat ride and showed us fishing and swimming spots. Joel and Sara live on the property. It was nice knowing they were close by in case we needed anything. They even have a bait shop (worms, leeches and minnows) and a small store with all the basic needs. If you are looking for a quiet, secluded spot for a vacation, Mystic Moose is the place. Joel and Sara, thank you very much for making our trip a success!

IA
Israr Ahmed Jan 20, 2026
10

Mystic Moose is one of the most peaceful resorts I've been too. The owners are incredibly friendly and treat you like family. Joel offered us some Chicken of the woods mushrooms he foraged, and Sara asked if we needed anything from town when she had to run errands. The cabins are neat and cozy, and have everything you need for a nice and peaceful stay. They offer kayaking, boat rentals, and paddle boats. They have a great place for a bond fire and keep stock of wood, playground for kids to play in, and WIF!!!

CT
Chet Toczek Jan 12, 2026
10

This was our first vacation in 12 years. I have to say if you love to fish, yet hate crowds and jet skiers everywhere, this is a little chunk of heaven nestled in the north woods. Joel and Sara Miller are the new owners, and I must say some of the best people I've met in a long time. The cabins are spotless, the grounds are well manicured, live bait on sight, are just a few of the many reasons why we will be coming back. The fishing was great!! Joel put us on the fish immediately. First time fishing stained water made me nervous. By the end of the week, I am confident next year will be even better. But what is nice, is the Millers treated us like family. Cheers Joel and Sara!! Have a great season, we will see you next year.

SA
Sue Ackermann Jan 11, 2026
10

This resort is always a sanctuary. It's quiet and beautiful. The cabins are very clean and Joel and Sarah ( the owners) always make us feel like family . They do so much to make everyone feel welcome. This is my favorite trip of the year. Kim and Sue Ackermann And Peedy Sue

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Mystic Moose Resort

New Post, Wisconsin, USA

Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around

  • Gogebic - Iron County Airport 1 hr 29 Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Lake Chippewa 23 reviews

Lake Chippewa

Hunter, WI, USA

5 · Lake
Lost Land Lake 24 reviews

Lost Land Lake

Spider Lake, WI 54843, USA

4.4 · Lake
Moose Lake 3 reviews

Moose Lake

Forest Service Road 176, Hayward, WI 54843, United States

4.7 · Tourist Attraction
People also viewed

Similar Resort Hotels in Wisconsin

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

1709 Sugarland Dr, Sheridan, WY 82801, United States

Candlewood Suites Sheridan by IHG

Stay at Candlewood Suites Sheridan by IHG, an allsuite hotel with gym, convenience store, and BBQ area near Sheridan County Museu...

4.4 (325) View
520 S Bolingbrook Dr, Bolingbrook, IL 60440, United States

Best Western Bolingbrook Hotel

Enjoy a 4.6star stay at Best Western Bolingbrook Hotel, IL. LGBTQ+ friendly with easy access to The Morton Arboretum and Chicago ...

4.6 (89) View
6401 Airport Fwy, Haltom City, TX 76117, United States

Red Roof Inn Haltom City

Red Roof Inn Haltom City offers free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms. Conveniently located near Fort Worth attractions and ...

3.9 (81) View
607 E Yakima Ave, Yakima, WA 98901, United States

Red Lion Hotel Yakima Center

Enjoy a 3.5star stay at Red Lion Hotel Yakima Center with free airport shuttle, outdoor pools, and onsite dining opposite Yakima ...

3.5 (987) View
1475 S Colorado Blvd, Denver, CO 80222, United States

Courtyard by Marriott Denver Cherry Creek

Stay at Courtyard by Marriott Denver Cherry Creek, a 4.1star hotel with a pool, restaurant, and meeting services near Denver Art ...

4.1 (1,611) View
21400 Farm to Market Rd 901, Gordonville, TX 76245, United States

Rock Creek

Experience Rock Creek Resort Hotel, a 4.3star resort with a private golf course in Gordonville, TX. Read 268 reviews and book a s...

4.3 (268) View
18 McGinnis Ln, Lake George, NY 12845, United States

Lee's Motel & Cottages

Stay at Lee's Motel & Cottages in Lake George, NY. Enjoy free WiFi, outdoor pool, kidfriendly rooms, and easy access to Six Flag...

4.4 (83) View
3838 SW Military Dr, San Antonio, TX 78211, United States

MID Town Inn Motel

MID Town Inn Motel offers free WiFi and parking in San Antonio near The Alamo, River Walk & Missions. 61 reviews rate it 3.3 star...

3.3 (61) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Mystic Moose Resort? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.